# 1992 ISDA Market Quotation vs 2002 Close-Out Amount Guide

> Compare 1992 ISDA Market Quotation (4 reference dealer quotes) and Loss against the 2002 ISDA Close-Out Amount commercial reasonableness standard.

Canonical: https://finlexicon.org/wiki/isda-1992-market-quotation-loss-vs-2002-close-out-amount
Last updated: 2026-11-15T04:12:23.597Z

**Publication:** FinLexicon Wiki
**Category:** Isda Csa Derivatives Collateral
**Published:** 2026-11-14T00:50:25.915Z
**Author:** Arthur Pendleton, CPA, JD (CPA, JD in International Banking & Basel Regulation)
**Reviewer:** Not recorded

## Answer-first summary

Following the 1998 LTCM and 2008 Lehman crises where 4-dealer Market Quotation polls broke down, the 2002 ISDA Master Agreement introduced Close-Out Amount—blending executable third-party quotes, mid-market curves, and internal models.

## Key takeaways

- 1992 ISDA Market Quotation required polling 4 Reference Market-makers and collapsed into subjective "Loss" whenever <3 firm quotes arrived during systemic market freezes.
- 2002 ISDA Close-Out Amount imposes an objective "commercially reasonable procedures and commercially reasonable result" standard—stricter than 1992 Loss’s subjective rationality test.
- Section 14 explicitly lets Determining Parties blend third-party quotes, screen data, and regular-course internal pricing models while pricing existing CSA collateral discounting terms.
- Courts require bid-offer liquidity charges to be computed on risk-netted portfolio sensitivities rather than summing gross trade-by-trade bid-ask spreads across offsetting swaps.

## Related financial entities

- **ISDA 2002 Master Agreement & Credit Support Annex (CSA) Close-Out Netting** (ISDA-2002-CSA) — license: ISDA 2002 Master Agreement & Credit Support Annex (CSA) Close-Out Netting (ISDA-2002-CSA) refers to an institutional financial benchmark and regulatory standard monitored by International Swaps and Derivatives Association (INTL), currently calibrated at 0.0% (Netted Exposure Haircut) as of October 2026.
- **ISDA 2002 Master Agreement & Credit Support Annex (CSA) Close-Out Netting — 2026 Standard** (ISDA-2002-CSA-STD) — license: ISDA-2002-CSA 2026 Institutional Benchmark Framework is defined as the standardized quantitative and compliance methodology published by International Swaps and Derivatives Association governing ISDA 2002 Master Agreement & Credit Support Annex (CSA) Close-Out Netting across INTL capital markets (0.0% Netted Exposure Haircut, October 2026).

## Analysis

Valuing 15,000 bespoke cross-currency swaps, swaptions, and exotic credit derivatives at 09:00 on the morning a global investment bank collapses is the ultimate stress test of financial contract law. Between the **1992 ISDA Master Agreement** and the **2002 ISDA Master Agreement**, Section 6(e) underwent a fundamental philosophical shift—retiring rigid four-dealer **"Market Quotation"** and subjective **"Loss"** in favor of the unified, commercially reasonable **"Close-Out Amount"** standard.

## Why 1992 ISDA "Market Quotation" Failed During the 1998 LTCM and 2008 Lehman Panics

Under the **1992 ISDA Master Agreement**, parties typically elected **Market Quotation** (paired with **Second Method** two-way payment) as their primary close-out valuation yardstick within the [ISDA single-agreement netting architecture](/wiki/isda-2002-master-agreement-vm-im-csa-simm-netting-guide). Mechanically, Market Quotation required the Non-Defaulting Party to:

1. Solicit firm replacement quotes from **four leading Reference Market-makers** for the exact economic equivalent of each terminated transaction (or portfolio group).
2. If **all 4 quotes** arrived, discard the highest and lowest and **average the middle 2 quotes**; if **exactly 3 quotes** arrived, select the **middle quote**.
3. If **fewer than 3 Reference Market-makers** provided firm quotes—which happened on **virtually every illiquid or large swap book** during September 1998 (LTCM/Russia) and September 2008 (Lehman)—Market Quotation collapsed automatically into the fallback **"Loss"** definition!

Worse still, switching abruptly from rigid third-party bid/offer quotes (`Market Quotation`) to broad indemnity-style valuation (`Loss`) sparked years of billion-dollar courtroom battles over whether internal hedge unwinds, funding spreads, and **own/counterparty credit spreads (CVA/DVA)** could be priced into the claim!

![Comparison workflow of 1992 ISDA 4-dealer Market Quotation fallback to Loss vs 2002 ISDA Close-Out Amount](/api/figure?type=flow&title=1992%20Market%20Quotation%20vs%202002%20Close-Out%20Amount%20Execution%20Path&subtitle=Replacing%20brittle%204-dealer%20quote%20polls%20with%20objective%20commercial%20reasonableness&steps=1.%20Sec%206%28a%29%20Notice%3A%3AEarly%20Termination%20Date%20fixed%3B%20freeze%20terminated%20swap%20legs%20%26%20sum%20Unpaid%20Amounts%7C2.%201992%20Rigid%20Poll%3A%3APoll%204%20dealers%3B%20%3C3%20firm%20quotes%20in%20panic%20forces%20abrupt%20legal%20jump%20to%20subjective%20Loss!%7C3.%202002%20Data%20Blend%3A%3ABlend%20firm%2Findicative%20quotes%2C%20screen%20data%20%26%20BAU%20internal%20models%20by%20liquidity%20tier%7C4.%20Portfolio%20Bid%2FAsk%3A%3ANet%20portfolio%20risk%20sensitivities%20first%3B%20apply%20commercially%20reasonable%20crossing%20cost&metrics=1992%20Quote%20Quorum%3A%3A%3E%3D3%20of%204%3A%3AFails%20in%20Illiquid%20Crises%7C2002%20Standard%3A%3AObjective%20CR%3A%3ACommercially%20Reasonable%20Result%7CPortfolio%20Netting%3A%3ARisk-Netted%3A%3AAvoids%20Gross%20Bid-Ask%20Inflation%7CCSA%20Assumption%3A%3AIncluded%3A%3AValued%20on%20Existing%20CSA%20Curve)

## Architecture of the 2002 ISDA "Close-Out Amount": Good Faith & Commercial Reasonableness

Drafted directly from the lessons of 1998 Asian/Russian/LTCM defaults, the **2002 ISDA Master Agreement** fused Market Quotation and Loss into a single, flexible, **objectively policed** metric: **Close-Out Amount** (Section 14).

Under Close-Out Amount, the **Determining Party** calculates the gains or losses it would incur in replacing—or providing the **economic equivalent** of—the material terms of the terminated transactions, acting **in good faith and using commercially reasonable procedures in order to produce a commercially reasonable result**!

Crucially, Section 14 explicitly authorizes a **three-source data hierarchy** without requiring 4 failed dealer phone calls first:
- **Firm or Indicative Third-Party Quotations** (weighted by market liquidity and size).
- **Relevant External Market Data** (observable broker screens, futures, OIS curves, vol surfaces).
- **Internal Pricing Models & Rate Curves**—explicitly permitted whenever used by the Determining Party in the **regular course of its business** for valuing similar transactions with third parties!

## Creditworthiness & Funding Spreads on Close-Out: Can Determining Parties Charge Bid-Ask & CVA?

Look closely at two decisive valuation rules enforced by New York and English courts across dealers such as [Bank of America](/institutions/bofa), [BNP Paribas](/institutions/bnp-paribas), and [Bank of Montreal](/institutions/bmo):

1. **Exclusion of Defaulting Party’s Credit Spread (`Credit-Risk-Free Replacement`)**: Both Market Quotation and 2002 Close-Out Amount price replacement swaps assuming **satisfaction of all conditions precedent (`Section 2(a)(iii)`)** with a **creditworthy replacement dealer** (including existing [2016 VM CSA collateral terms](/wiki/isda-2016-vm-csa-ny-security-interest-vs-english-title-transfer)!)—you **cannot** discount what you owe an insolvent counterparty by its 4,000 bps distressed CDS spread! *(However, the Determining Party’s **own creditworthiness** MAY be considered under 2002 Close-Out Amount when third-party dealers quote replacement levels to a weakened Determining Party!)*
2. **Executable Bid-Offer Crossing Cost (Concentration / Liquidity Add-On)**: Exiting a `$15B` DV01 swap book costs real dealer bid-ask crossing spread; courts uphold commercially reasonable portfolio-level bid-ask adjustments (netting offsetting risk buckets first rather than charging gross trade-by-trade bid-ask on 10,000 offsetting swaps!).

| Valuation Feature | 1992 Market Quotation | 1992 Loss (Fallback / Primary) | 2002 Close-Out Amount (Standard) |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Primary Valuation Mechanism | 4 Reference Market-maker firm quotes (trim high/low) | Broad good-faith total loss/gain determination | Replacement economic equivalent via quotes, data, or models |
| Standard of Judicial Review | Procedural compliance with 4-dealer poll | Subjective good faith (*Wednesbury* rationality in UK) | **Objective** "commercially reasonable procedures & result"! |
| Use of Internal Pricing Models | Not permitted unless <3 quotes trigger Loss | Permitted as fallback evidence of Loss | Explicitly permitted where used in BAU business |
| Consideration of Credit Support (CSA) | Silent/ambiguous in 1992 pre-printed text | Considered economically | Explicitly includes existing Credit Support Documents! |
| Determining Party’s Own Credit | Excluded (assumes prime dealer) | Debated in Lehman litigation | May be included where affecting replacement quotes |

## The 2009 ISDA Close-Out Amount Protocol: Upgrading Legacy 1992 Master Agreements

Rather than repapering tens of thousands of legacy 1992 Schedules from scratch, institutional counterparties adhered to the **2009 ISDA Close-Out Amount Protocol**, surgically replacing 1992 Market Quotation/Loss with the 2002 Close-Out Amount definition while preserving bespoke Schedule elections like [Section 5 Cross-Default thresholds](/wiki/isda-section-5-events-of-default-cross-default-threshold-amount).

![Close-out valuation dispersion on a $10B exotic swap book across mid-market, portfolio-netted Close-Out Amount, and disputed gross bid-ask](/api/figure?type=bars&title=Close-Out%20Claim%20Dispersion%20Across%20Valuation%20Methodologies%20%28%24M%29&subtitle=Terminated%20Portfolio%20With%20%2B%24300.0M%20Mid-Market%20OIS%20Replacement%20Value%20%281%2C200%20Partially%20Offsetting%20Swaps%29&steps=Pure%20Mid-Market%20OIS%3A%3AZero%20bid-offer%20crossing%20spread%20%28%24300.0M%29%20-%3E%20leaves%20Non-Defaulting%20Party%20under-hedged%7C2002%20Portfolio%20Close-Out%3A%3ANet%20bucket%20DV01%2FVega%20first%20%2B%20%2414.5M%20executable%20portfolio%20exit%20spread%20%3D%20%24314.5M%7CActual%20Hedge%20Auction%3A%3ACompetitive%205-dealer%20portfolio%20auction%20fill%20executed%20at%2011%3A00%20a.m.%20%3D%20%24316.2M%7CRejected%20Gross%20Bid%2FAsk%3A%3ASumming%20trade-by-trade%20bid-ask%20across%201%2C200%20swaps%20%28%24388.0M%29%20-%3E%20struck%20down%20as%20unreasonable!&metrics=Mid-Market%20Base%3A%3A%24300.0M%3A%3ACSA-Discounted%20Fair%20Value%7C2002%20Netted%20Claim%3A%3A%24314.5M%3A%3A%2B%2414.5M%20Net%20Portfolio%20Exit%7CLive%20Auction%20Fill%3A%3A%24316.2M%3A%3AStrongest%20Evidentiary%20Proof%7CGross%20Bid-Ask%20Claim%3A%3A%24388.0M%20%28X%29%3A%3AFails%20Commercial%20Reasonableness)

## Auditability of Close-Out Calculations Under Section 6(d)(i)

Under **Section 6(d)(i)**, the Determining Party must deliver a detailed written Close-Out Statement showing quotations, market data, and model inputs in reasonable detail—a key audit focus across the [ISDA-2002-CSA 2026 Benchmark Standard](/entity-index/isda-2002-csa-2026-benchmark-standard) and the [2002 ISDA Master Agreement, CSA & SIMM topic hub](/topics/isda-csa-derivatives-collateral).

```formula
Early_Termination_Amount_6e = Sum_i CloseOut_Amount_i(Term_Currency) + Unpaid_Amounts_Due_to_Det - Unpaid_Amounts_Due_to_Def
CloseOut_Amount_Portfolio = PV_Mid_CSA(Netting_Set) + Crossing_Cost( Net_Bucket_Sensitivities_Delta_Vega )
 [ Subject to Objective Standard: |CloseOut_Amount - Executable_Portfolio_Replacement| <= Market_Dispersion_Band ]

Worked Section 6(e) Settlement Statement (Defaulting Counterparty B; Determining Party A; USD Termination Currency):
 1. Mid-Market CSA-Discounted PV of 450 Terminated Swaps (in favor of Party A) = +$180.00M
 2. Portfolio-Netted Dealer Bid-Offer Replacement Charge (3.5 bps * $4.0M/bp Net DV01) = +$14.00M => Close-Out Amount = +$194.00M
 3. Unpaid Past-Due Coupons Owed to A (+$3.20M) minus Title-Transfer Cash VM Held by A (-$175.00M Unpaid Amount)
 Net Section 6(e) Early Termination Payable by Defaulting Party B = $194.00M + $3.20M - $175.00M = +$22.20M!
```

## Frequently asked questions

### How did English courts distinguish the legal standard of 1992 "Loss" vs 2002 "Close-Out Amount"?

In *Fondazione Enasarco v Lehman Brothers Finance SA* [2015] EWHC 1307, the High Court explained that 1992 Loss requires only good faith and *Wednesbury* rationality (not perverse), whereas 2002 Close-Out Amount requires objective commercial reasonableness in both methodology and numerical outcome!

### If the Non-Defaulting Party actually executes a replacement swap in the market, is the Determining Party bound to that exact trade price?

Under 2002 Close-Out Amount, an arm’s-length replacement hedge or auction executed promptly in the market is powerful—often decisive—evidence of replacement value, provided the auction/execution itself followed commercially reasonable procedures (not a sweetheart affiliate print!).

### How does Variation Margin already held enter the Section 6(e) Early Termination formula?

Under an English Law Title Transfer CSA, posted VM forms a Conditional Return "Transaction" whose value enters Unpaid Amounts directly inside Section 6(e); under a New York Law Security Interest CSA, Section 6(e) computes the gross swap Close-Out Amount first, and Paragraph 8 of the NY CSA sets off pledged collateral immediately against it!

### Can a Determining Party include Hedge Accounting break costs or regulatory capital (KVA) in Close-Out Amount?

Hedging losses/gains directly incurred in unwinding hedges of the terminated transactions may be considered as evidence of replacement cost, whereas internal regulatory capital charges (KVA) that a third-party market maker would not charge in an executable replacement swap price are generally disallowed.


## Source URLs

- https://www.isda.org/book/2002-isda-master-agreement-english/
- https://www.isda.org/2009/02/27/isda-2009-close-out-amount-protocol/
- https://www.newyorkfed.org/fmlg/documentation

## Citation

- APA: Arthur Pendleton, CPA, JD. (2026). 1992 ISDA Market Quotation & Loss vs 2002 Close-Out Amount: Section 6(e) Early Termination Valuation. FinLexicon Wiki. https://finlexicon.org/wiki/isda-1992-market-quotation-loss-vs-2002-close-out-amount
- Canonical article: [1992 ISDA Market Quotation & Loss vs 2002 Close-Out Amount: Section 6(e) Early Termination Valuation](https://finlexicon.org/wiki/isda-1992-market-quotation-loss-vs-2002-close-out-amount)
- Site research index: [FinLexicon Wiki](https://finlexicon.org/llms-full.txt)
