# Regulatory Grid Schedule IM & NGR Formula vs ISDA SIMM

> Calculate BCBS-IOSCO Regulatory Grid Schedule Initial Margin: 1%–15% notional weights, the Net-to-Gross Ratio (0.4 + 0.6*NGR) offset, and when Grid beats SIMM.

Canonical: https://finlexicon.org/wiki/regulatory-grid-schedule-im-vs-isda-simm-ngr-netting-offset
Last updated: 2026-11-15T14:57:48.016Z

**Publication:** FinLexicon Wiki
**Category:** Isda Csa Derivatives Collateral
**Published:** 2026-11-13T22:45:25.915Z
**Author:** Arthur Pendleton, CPA, JD (CPA, JD in International Banking & Basel Regulation)
**Reviewer:** Not recorded

## Answer-first summary

For Phase 6 end-users seeking to avoid CRIF sensitivity infrastructure—or holding one-way directional hedges—the BCBS-IOSCO Standardized Grid Schedule computes Initial Margin using 1%–15% notional weights scaled by 0.4 + 0.6*NGR.

## Key takeaways

- BCBS-IOSCO’s Standardized Grid Schedule charges 1%/2%/4% on IRS, 2%/5%/10% on CDS, 6% on FX options/NDFs, and 15% on equities/commodities—requiring zero Greek sensitivity models.
- The 0.4 + 0.6 * NGR formula caps portfolio netting relief at 60%: even two 100% equal-and-opposite offsetting swaps retain a permanent 40% of gross notional Grid IM charge unless compressed!
- Unlike ISDA SIMM (where IM collected by Party A equals IM posted by Party A), Grid IM is asymmetric because NGR uses current positive MTM from each counterparty’s side.
- Counterparties may elect Grid for minor asset classes (e.g., Commodities) while running SIMM on core Rates/FX, subject to strict regulatory anti-cherry-picking governance.

## Related financial entities

- **ISDA 2002 Master Agreement & Credit Support Annex (CSA) Close-Out Netting** (ISDA-2002-CSA) — license: ISDA 2002 Master Agreement & Credit Support Annex (CSA) Close-Out Netting (ISDA-2002-CSA) refers to an institutional financial benchmark and regulatory standard monitored by International Swaps and Derivatives Association (INTL), currently calibrated at 0.0% (Netted Exposure Haircut) as of October 2026.
- **ISDA 2002 Master Agreement & Credit Support Annex (CSA) Close-Out Netting — 2026 Standard** (ISDA-2002-CSA-STD) — license: ISDA-2002-CSA 2026 Institutional Benchmark Framework is defined as the standardized quantitative and compliance methodology published by International Swaps and Derivatives Association governing ISDA 2002 Master Agreement & Credit Support Annex (CSA) Close-Out Netting across INTL capital markets (0.0% Netted Exposure Haircut, October 2026).

## Analysis

Running [ISDA SIMM](/wiki/isda-simm-v2-6-delta-vega-curvature-risk-weights-correlations) requires daily option-surface pricing engines, CRIF sensitivity generation, quarterly backtesting, and model governance fees. For smaller [UMR Phase 6](/wiki/umr-phase-6-regulatory-initial-margin-50m-threshold-ana-aana) insurers, endowments, and corporate pension funds—and surprisingly even for **purely directional one-way duration hedges**—BCBS-IOSCO Annex A provides a zero-Greek regulatory alternative: the **Standardized Regulatory Grid ("Schedule") Initial Margin** coupled with the **Net-to-Gross Ratio (`0.4 + 0.6 * NGR`)** netting formula!

## The Official BCBS-IOSCO Standardized Grid Table (1% to 15% of Gross Notional)

Codified identically across U.S. Prudential (`12 CFR Part 237 Appendix A`), CFTC (`17 CFR 23.154(c)`), EU EMIR RTS Annex IV, and [UK PRA](/regulators/prudential-regulation-authority-uk-173) rulebooks within our [2002 ISDA Master Agreement & UMR cornerstone guide](/wiki/isda-2002-master-agreement-vm-im-csa-simm-netting-guide), the **Regulatory Grid** multiplies each trade’s **gross notional principal** by a fixed statutory percentage:

- **Interest Rate Swaps, Swaptions & Inflation**: **1.0%** (`< 2 years` residual maturity), **2.0%** (`2 to 5 years`), **4.0%** (`> 5 years`—notice a 6-year swap and a 50-year swap both get **4.0%**!).
- **Credit Derivatives (CDS)**: **2.0%** (`< 2 years`), **5.0%** (`2 to 5 years`), **10.0%** (`> 5 years`).
- **Foreign Exchange (Non-Exempt FX Options / NDFs)**: **6.0%** across all maturities *(physically settled FX forwards/swaps are **0% exempt** from UMR IM!)*. 
- **Equities & Commodities**: **15.0%** across all maturities!
- **Other / Bespoke Exotics**: **15.0%** across all maturities.

![BCBS-IOSCO Regulatory Grid Schedule Initial Margin and 0.4 + 0.6*NGR calculation pipeline](/api/figure?type=flow&title=BCBS-IOSCO%20Standardized%20Grid%20Schedule%20IM%20Calculation%20Engine&subtitle=Computing%20zero-Greek%20notional%20margin%20with%2040%25%E2%80%93100%25%20Net-to-Gross%20Ratio%20scaling&steps=1.%20Grid%20Weight%20Lookup%3A%3AApply%201%25%2F2%25%2F4%25%20IRS%2C%202%25%2F5%25%2F10%25%20CDS%2C%206%25%20FX%20Opt%2FNDF%2C%20or%2015%25%20Equity%2FCmdty%20to%20Notional%7C2.%20Sum%20Gross%20Grid%20IM%3A%3AAggregate%20Gross_IM%20%3D%20Sum_i%20%28Grid_Weight_i%20*%20Notional_Principal_i%29%20across%20set%7C3.%20Compute%20MTM%20NGR%3A%3ANGR%20%3D%20max%280%2C%20Sum%20MTM_i%29%20%2F%20Sum%20max%280%2C%20MTM_i%29%20%20%5BAsymmetric%20per%20party%20perspective!%5D%7C4.%20Apply%2060%25%20Relief%3A%3ANet_Schedule_IM%20%3D%20%280.40%20%2B%200.60%20*%20NGR%29%20*%20Gross_IM%20%20%28Floored%20at%2040%25%20of%20Gross_IM!%29&metrics=IRS%20Grid%20%28%3E5Y%29%3A%3A4.0%25%20Notional%3A%3A1%25%20%28%3C2Y%29%20%2F%202%25%20%282Y%E2%80%935Y%29%7CFX%20Opt%20%2F%20NDF%20Grid%3A%3A6.0%25%20Notional%3A%3APhysical%20FX%20%3D%200%25%20Exempt%7CEquity%20%26%20Cmdty%3A%3A15.0%25%20Notional%3A%3AFlat%20Across%20All%20Tenors%7CMax%20NGR%20Discount%3A%3A-60.0%25%20Relief%3A%3A40%25%20Hard%20Gross%20Floor)

## How the `0.4 + 0.6 * NGR` Formula Grants Up to 60% Portfolio Netting Relief

Summing `Gross_Initial_Margin = Sum_i (Grid_%_i * Notional_i)` blindly across a portfolio of offsetting swaps would charge double margin whenever a fund unwound an existing swap by entering an equal-and-opposite offsetting trade! To recognize bilateral close-out netting without computing sensitivities, BCBS-IOSCO borrowed the classic Basel II CEM **Net-to-Gross Ratio (`NGR`)** scalar:

1. Compute **Net Replacement Cost (`Net_RC = max(0, Sum_i MTM_i)`)** across all UMR-covered trades in the netting set.
2. Compute **Gross Replacement Cost (`Gross_RC = Sum_i max(0, MTM_i)`)**—the sum of strictly positive mark-to-market trades.
3. Set `NGR = Net_RC / Gross_RC` (`NGR in [0, 1]`; set `NGR = 1.0` if `Gross_RC == 0` on Day 0 when all swaps are freshly struck at par!).
4. Compute **`Net_Standardized_IM = ( 0.40 + 0.60 * NGR ) * Gross_Initial_Margin`**!

## Two Astonishing Mathematical Quirks of `0.4 + 0.6 * NGR` Every Quant Must Know

Examine the `NGR` formula closely across institutional portfolios facing [Bank of America](/institutions/bofa), [BNP Paribas](/institutions/bnp-paribas), and [Bank of Montreal](/institutions/bmo)—it hides two counterintuitive behaviors:

- **Quirk #1 (Day-0 Par Trap vs Out-of-the-Money Drop!)**: Suppose a pension fund enters a brand-new `$1.0B` 30-year SOFR receiver swap at par (`MTM = $0`). At Day 0 (`Gross_RC = 0`), `NGR = 1.0`, so `Grid_IM = 4.0% * $1.0B = $40.0M`. Tomorrow, rates rise `+5 bps` so the swap moves **-$10M out-of-the-money** to the fund (`MTM = -$10M`)! Now `Net_RC = max(0, -$10M) = $0`, while for **the dealer** `Net_RC = +$10M` (`NGR_dealer = 1.0`, `NGR_fund = 0.0` if another tiny `+$1k` trade exists)! Suddenly **one side’s Grid IM drops 60% (`0.4 * $40M = $16M`) while the other side stays at `$40M`**—making Grid IM **asymmetric** between Party A and Party B (unlike symmetric ISDA SIMM!)!
- **Quirk #2 (30-Year Duration Arbitrage vs SIMM)**: On a **30-year zero-coupon or par receiver swap**, true DV01 is `~21 bps/$`, so **ISDA SIMM charges ~13.4% of notional** (`21 * 64 bps`), whereas **Grid caps >5Y IRS flat at 4.0% of notional**! However, remember the **strict no-cherry-picking rule** (`BCBS d499` / [ECB](/regulators/european-central-bank-160) EMIR): you cannot flip between Grid and SIMM Opportunistically!

| Asset Class & Residual Maturity | Regulatory Grid % of Notional | Typical ISDA SIMM Equivalent | Symmetry Between Party A & B | Best Institutional Use Case |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Interest Rate (`< 2Y` / `2–5Y` / `> 5Y`) | 1.0% / 2.0% / 4.0% | ~0.6% (1Y) to ~13.5% (30Y!) | Grid Asymmetric (`NGR`); SIMM Symmetric | Small sub-$50M TH funds or ultra-long 30Y |
| Credit Derivatives (`< 2Y` / `2–5Y` / `> 5Y`) | 2.0% / 5.0% / 10.0% | ~1.2% (IG Index) to ~18% (HY) | Grid penalizes IG CDX/iTraxx hedges heavily | Rarely optimal for active CDS desks |
| FX Options & Non-Deliverable Forwards | 6.0% (All maturities) | ~3.5%–8.5% (net Delta + Vega) | Grid ignores Delta-hedged FX option offsets | Low-notional NDF hedgers (<$800M) |
| Equity Swaps & Options (EU/UK UMR) | 15.0% (All maturities) | ~14%–28% (net long/short beta) | Grid charges 15% on BOTH long & short legs! | Minor single-trade sleeve carve-out |
| Commodities (Swaps, Forwards & Options) | 15.0% (All maturities) | ~16% (Gold) to ~55% (Gas/Power) | Grid ignores calendar-spread offsets | Non-core commodity sleeve on IR bank |

## Hybrid Election: Using SIMM on Rates/FX While Using Grid on Minor Commodity/Equity Sleeves

Both U.S. UMR and EU/UK EMIR permit **Risk-Class-Level Election**: an insurer running 99% interest-rate and FX hedges on SIMM with three small legacy commodity swaps may elect **Grid (`15%`) solely for the Commodity class** rather than building a full commodity CRIF engine!

![Comparison of Grid Schedule IM vs ISDA SIMM across hedged relative-value swaps and unhedged 30-year duration swaps](/api/figure?type=bars&title=Portfolio%20Netting%20Penalty%20in%20Grid%20vs%20SIMM%20%28%24M%20Margin%20Required%29&subtitle=Comparing%20Two%20%242.0B%20Gross%20Notional%20Books%3A%20Equal-and-Opposite%20Unwind%20vs%20Unhedged%2030Y%20Swap&steps=Unwound%2010Y%20Pair%20%28SIMM%29%3A%3A%2B%241B%20Pay-Fixed%20%26%20-%241B%20Rec-Fixed%2010Y%20SOFR%3A%20Net%20DV01%20%3D%200%20-%3E%20ISDA%20SIMM%20%3D%20%240.0M!%7CUnwound%2010Y%20Pair%20%28Grid%29%3A%3AGross%20Grid%20%3D%204%25%20*%20%242B%20%3D%20%2480M%3B%20even%20at%20NGR%20%3D%200%2C%2040%25%20floor%20locks%20in%20%2432.0M%20forever!%7CDirectional%2030Y%20%28Grid%29%3A%3ASingle%20%241B%2030Y%20Par%20Swap%3A%20Grid%20caps%20%3E5Y%20IRS%20at%204.0%25%20*%20%241B%20%3D%20%2440.0M%7CDirectional%2030Y%20%28SIMM%29%3A%3ASingle%20%241B%2030Y%20Par%20Swap%20%28%242.1M%2Fbp%20DV01%20*%2064%20bps%20RW%29%3A%20ISDA%20SIMM%20%3D%20%24134.4M!&metrics=Offset%20Pair%20SIMM%3A%3A%240.0M%20Margin%3A%3A100%25%20Exact%20Risk%20Offset%7COffset%20Pair%20Grid%3A%3A%2432.0M%20Stuck!%3A%3A40%25%20Gross%20Notional%20Floor%7C30Y%20Swap%20Grid%3A%3A%2440.0M%20%284.0%25%29%3A%3AFlat%20%3E5Y%20Maturity%20Cap%7C30Y%20Swap%20SIMM%3A%3A%24134.4M%20%2813.4%25%29%3A%3AFull%2030Y%20DV01%20Scaling)

## Operational Adoption of Grid for Sub-$50M Phase 6 Threshold Monitoring

Many newly in-scope `$9B` AANA funds use Grid (`<= $15M` total IM) to prove effortlessly to dealers that their portfolio sits far below the [$50M group IM threshold](/wiki/umr-phase-6-regulatory-initial-margin-50m-threshold-ana-aana), documented across the [ISDA-2002-CSA 2026 Benchmark Standard](/entity-index/isda-2002-csa-2026-benchmark-standard) and the [2002 ISDA Master Agreement, CSA & SIMM topic hub](/topics/isda-csa-derivatives-collateral).

```formula
Gross_Grid_IM = Sum_{i=1..N} Grid_Factor(Asset_i, Residual_Mat_i) * Notional_i
NGR_Party_X = max( 0 , Sum_i MTM_{X,i} ) / Sum_i max( 0 , MTM_{X,i} ) [ defined = 1.0 if Denominator == 0 ]
Net_Schedule_IM = ( 0.40 + 0.60 * NGR_Party_X ) * Gross_Grid_IM

Worked Asymmetric NGR Audit (Party A vs Party B on 2 Swaps: Swap 1 = $500M 7Y IRS [MTM to A = +$15M]; Swap 2 = $500M 7Y IRS [MTM to A = -$25M]):
 Gross_Grid_IM (Both Parties) = 4.0% * $500M + 4.0% * $500M = $20.0M + $20.0M = $40.00M
 From Party A View (Collecting IM): Net_RC_A = max(0, +$15M - $25M) = $0 | Gross_RC_A = +$15M => NGR_A = $0 / $15M = 0.00!
 IM Collected by Party A = (0.40 + 0.60 * 0.00) * $40.0M = $16.00M
 From Party B View (Collecting IM): Net_RC_B = max(0, -$15M + $25M) = +$10M | Gross_RC_B = +$25M => NGR_B = $10M / $25M = 0.40!
 IM Collected by Party B = (0.40 + 0.60 * 0.40) * $40.0M = 0.64 * $40.0M = $25.60M! (Asymmetric two-way Grid IM!)
```

## Frequently asked questions

### Why does an unwound swap pair still carry a 40% Gross Grid IM floor instead of dropping to zero?

Because Net_Schedule_IM = (0.40 + 0.60 * NGR) * Gross_IM floors the multiplier at 0.40 even when NGR = 0! Only legally tearing up and terminating the two offsetting trades (bilateral tear-up or multilateral compression) eliminates their gross notional!

### Can Party A calculate IM using ISDA SIMM while its counterparty Party B calculates IM on the exact same CSA using the Grid Schedule?

Yes! Because UMR requires two-way IM collection (Party A as Secured Party collects IM calculated under Party A’s approved model, while Party B as Secured Party collects IM under Party B’s compliant method), a G-SIB dealer may collect SIMM from a small insurer while the insurer collects Grid from the dealer (or delegates SIMM calculation to the dealer!).

### Why did Basel replace CEM’s 0.4 + 0.6 * NGR in bank capital (with SA-CCR) yet retain 0.4 + 0.6 * NGR inside the UMR Grid Schedule?

BCBS-IOSCO intentionally kept the fallback UMR Grid Schedule ultra-simple so small financial end-users swept into UMR would never be forced by law to license complex Greeks or SA-CCR software just to compute fallback initial margin.

### How are amortizing swaps and forward-starting swaps treated in the Grid notional and maturity lookup?

Grid uses current effective notional principal (stepping down as an amortizing swap pays down principal) and final legal maturity (end date minus today)—meaning a 1-year swap starting in 5 years (1y5y forward swap) lands in the > 5 years (4.0%) Grid bucket!


## Source URLs

- https://www.bis.org/bcbs/publ/d499.htm
- https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-12/chapter-II/subchapter-A/part-237/appendix-Appendix%20A%20to%20Subpart%20A%20of%20Part%20237
- https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-17/chapter-I/part-23/subpart-E/section-23.154

## Citation

- APA: Arthur Pendleton, CPA, JD. (2026). Regulatory Grid Schedule Initial Margin vs ISDA SIMM: Notional Percentages & the 0.4 + 0.6*NGR Formula. FinLexicon Wiki. https://finlexicon.org/wiki/regulatory-grid-schedule-im-vs-isda-simm-ngr-netting-offset
- Canonical article: [Regulatory Grid Schedule Initial Margin vs ISDA SIMM: Notional Percentages & the 0.4 + 0.6*NGR Formula](https://finlexicon.org/wiki/regulatory-grid-schedule-im-vs-isda-simm-ngr-netting-offset)
- Site research index: [FinLexicon Wiki](https://finlexicon.org/llms-full.txt)
