# IFRS 9 SPPI Test & 2024 ESG-Linked Loan Amendments Guide

> Pass the IFRS 9.4.1.2(b) SPPI (Solely Payments of Principal and Interest) test: basic lending rules, May 2024 IASB ESG-linked loans, and CLN tranches.

Canonical: https://finlexicon.org/wiki/sppi-solely-payments-principal-interest-esg-linked-loan-tests
Last updated: 2026-11-14T19:37:42.598Z

**Publication:** FinLexicon Wiki
**Category:** Ifrs9 Cecl Credit Provisioning
**Published:** 2026-11-13T15:40:25.915Z
**Author:** Arthur Pendleton, CPA, JD (CPA, JD in International Banking & Basel Regulation)
**Reviewer:** Not recorded

## Answer-first summary

Failing the IFRS 9 Solely Payments of Principal and Interest (SPPI) test forces loans into Fair Value Through Profit or Loss (FVTPL); examine the May 2024 IASB Amendments rescuing ESG sustainability-linked loans alongside non-recourse and tranche tests.

## Key takeaways

- Because IFRS 9 eliminated embedded-derivative bifurcation for financial assets, failing SPPI on even a minor clause forces 100% of the loan’s principal into FVTPL.
- Under the May 2024 IASB Amendments (effective Jan 1, 2026, early adoption open), ESG Sustainability-Linked Loans (+/-5–25 bps debtor carbon KPIs) pass SPPI so long as they are not linked to equity/commodity indices or borrower revenue/EBITDA.
- Constant-Maturity-Swap (CMS) loans, leveraged floaters, convertible bonds, and equity/first-loss CLO tranches fail SPPI and sit at FVTPL.
- Non-recourse SPV project/CRE loans pass SPPI only when look-through borrower equity cushions are thick enough that the lender is not taking disguised equity/asset-price risk.

## Related financial entities

- **Basel III 72.5% Standardized Risk-Weighted Asset (RWA) Output Floor** (BCBS-OUTPUT-FLOOR) — license: Basel III 72.5% Standardized Risk-Weighted Asset (RWA) Output Floor (BCBS-OUTPUT-FLOOR) refers to an institutional financial benchmark and regulatory standard monitored by Basel Committee (BCBS d424) (INTL), currently calibrated at 72.5% (Minimum RWA Floor) as of October 2026.
- **Basel III CET1 Capital Adequacy Standard** (BCBS-CET1) — license: International regulatory accord requiring Tier-1 common equity capital ratios, G-SIB surcharges, and liquidity buffers for banking institutions.

## Analysis

Under **IFRS 9 paragraphs 4.1.2(b) and 4.1.2A(b)**, even if a commercial bank intends to hold a 10-year corporate loan strictly to maturity (`Hold-to-Collect` business model), **failing the Solely Payments of Principal and Interest (`SPPI`) contractual cash-flow test by even 10 basis points of non-basic return disqualifies the entire loan from Amortized Cost and dumps 100% of the principal into Fair Value Through Profit or Loss (`FVTPL`)**! In **May 2024**, the IASB issued landmark targeted amendments to IFRS 9 and IFRS 7 (**effective January 1, 2026**, early adoption permitted) resolving the `$1.5+ trillion` **ESG Sustainability-Linked Loan (`SLL`)** SPPI crisis!

## Anatomy of a "Basic Lending Arrangement" Under IFRS 9.4.1.3 & B4.1.7A

Within our [IFRS 9 & ASC 326 CECL cornerstone guide](/wiki/ifrs-9-ecl-asc-326-cecl-fair-value-hedge-accounting-guide), IFRS 9 defines **Principal** as the **fair value of the financial asset at initial recognition** (adjusted for principal repayments), and **Interest** as consideration for:

1. **Time Value of Money** (compensating solely for passage of time—tested quantitatively when **modified time value** arises, e.g., a 1-month rate reset every 12 months or inverse floaters, which **fail** SPPI!).
2. **Credit Risk** associated with the principal amount outstanding.
3. **Other Basic Lending Risks & Costs** (liquidity risk and administrative servicing costs) **plus a Profit Margin**.

Conversely, **any contractual feature introducing exposure to risks or volatility unrelated to a basic lending arrangement**—such as **equity-price indexing, commodity-price indexing, borrower EBITDA/revenue profit-sharing ratchets, or convertible-bond options**—**FAILS SPPI**, mandating `FVTPL` mark-to-market across the entire asset (**IFRS 9 abolished IAS 39 embedded-derivative bifurcation on financial assets**, though **US GAAP `ASC 815` STILL bifurcates** embedded derivatives from host loans!).

![IFRS 9 Section 4.1 Business Model and SPPI decision tree incorporating May 2024 ESG contingent feature amendments](/api/figure?type=flow&title=IFRS%209%20Classification%20%26%202024%20SPPI%20Decision%20Tree&subtitle=Routing%20loans%2C%20ESG%20SLLs%2C%20Non-Recourse%20SPVs%2C%20and%20Securitization%20CLIs%20into%20AC%2C%20FVOCI%2C%20or%20FVTPL&steps=1.%20Basic%20Lending%20Test%3A%3ACheck%20Principal%20%2B%20Time%20Value%20%2B%20Credit%20Risk%3B%20reject%20equity%2Fcommodity%2FEBITDA%20links%20-%3E%20FVTPL%7C2.%202024%20Contingent%20Gate%3A%3ADebtor-specific%20ESG%20KPI%20w%2F%20bounded%20bps%20ratchet%20%28not%20profit%2Findex%20share%29%20-%3E%20PASSES%20SPPI!%7C3.%20Non-Recourse%20%2F%20CLI%3A%3ALook%20through%20SPV%20equity%20cushion%3B%20test%20CLI%20tranche%20credit%20risk%20%3C%3D%20underlying%20pool%20risk%7C4.%20Business%20Model%20Map%3A%3ASPPI%20Pass%20%2B%20Hold-to-Collect%20%3D%20Amortized%20Cost%20%20%20HTC%26S%20%3D%20FVOCI%20%20%20Other%2FFail%20%3D%20FVTPL&metrics=SPPI%20Failure%20Cost%3A%3A100%25%20FVTPL%3A%3AZero%20Embedded%20Bifurcation!%7CESG%20SLL%20Ratchet%3A%3A%2B%2F-5%20to%2025bp%3A%3APasses%20Under%20May%202024%20Rule%7C2024%20Effective%20Date%3A%3AJan%201%2C%202026%3A%3AEarly%20Adoption%20Permitted%7CCLI%20Junior%20Tranche%3A%3AFails%20SPPI%3A%3ATranche%20Risk%20%3E%20Pool%20Avg!)

## The ESG Sustainability-Linked Loan (`SLL`) Dilemma & the May 2024 IASB Contingent-Feature Test

Between 2019 and 2024, European and global lenders ([BNP Paribas](/institutions/bnp-paribas), [Bank of Montreal](/institutions/bmo), [ANZ Bank](/institutions/anz-bank), [ASN Bank](/institutions/asnbank)) originated hundreds of billions of **Sustainability-Linked Loans (`SLLs`)** where the coupon steps down **`-5 to -15 bps`** if the borrower cuts **Scope 1/2/3 carbon emissions by 30%** (or steps up `+10 bps` on missing the KPI).

- **Why SLLs Threatened to Fail Original IFRS 9 SPPI**: Is a `-10 bps` green carbon step-down strictly proportional to *borrower credit default risk*? Often **not** in a mathematical 1-for-1 sense—risking mass FVTPL reclassification!
- **May 2024 IASB Amendments (`IFRS 9.B4.1.8A–B4.1.10A`)**: Clarifies that a financial asset with a **contingent feature tied to a borrower-specific non-financial event (such as achieving an ESG carbon target)** **PASSES SPPI** provided **two guardrails** hold:
 1. Across **all** possible contractually specified scenarios (whether the ESG KPI is hit or missed!), the resulting cash flows represent SPPI (**NOT** indexed to an external market price, equity index, or borrower revenue/profit share!).
 2. The nature of the contingent event is **specific to the debtor** (not an external market index like Brent crude or gold!), and resulting cash flows are **not significantly different** from an identical plain-vanilla loan without the contingent feature!

## Non-Recourse Project Finance ("Look-Through") & Contractually Linked Instruments (`CLIs` / Securitizations)

Two additional SPPI minefields draw heavy scrutiny from [ECB](/regulators/european-central-bank-160), [UK PRA](/regulators/prudential-regulation-authority-uk-173), and Big-4 audit specialists:

- **Non-Recourse Loans (`IFRS 9.B4.1.16–17`)**: Lending to an SPV to build a toll road or commercial tower with zero parent guarantee requires **"looking through"** to the underlying assets: if thin SPV equity means the lender effectively absorbs **equity/asset-value upside and downside** rather than receiving capped principal + interest, the loan **fails SPPI (`FVTPL`)**!
- **Contractually Linked Instruments (`CLIs` — Securitization Tranches, `IFRS 9.B4.1.20–26`)**: A securitization tranche passes SPPI **ONLY** if **all three** hold: (a) the tranche’s own terms are SPPI, (b) the **underlying asset pool** contains `SPPI` instruments (`>=90%–100%` principal/interest loans + hedging derivatives), AND (c) **credit risk of the tranche is `<=` the weighted-average credit risk of the underlying pool**—meaning **senior/mezzanine tranches pass SPPI**, while **junior equity/first-loss tranches FAIL SPPI (`FVTPL`)**!

| Loan / Security Feature | IFRS 9 SPPI Outcome | IFRS 9 Accounting Category | US GAAP (`ASC 310` / `815`) Contrast |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| SOFR + 180 bps Corporate Loan w/ `-10 bps` Scope-1 CO2 KPI | **PASSES** (May 2024 Amendment) | Amortized Cost (Stage 1–3 ECL) | Amortized Cost (`ASC 815` scope exception) |
| Loan w/ Coupon Tied to Borrower **EBITDA or Revenue Growth**! | **FAILS SPPI** (Equity/business risk!) | **100% FVTPL** (No bifurcation!) | Host Loan @ Cost + Bifurcated Derivative! |
| Convertible Corporate Bond Held by Investor | **FAILS SPPI** (Equity conversion!) | **100% FVTPL** | Bifurcated or FVO / ASC 320 |
| 5x Leveraged Inverse Floater (`8.0% - 2 * SOFR`) | **FAILS SPPI** (Leverage/non-basic TVM) | **100% FVTPL** | Host @ Cost + Bifurcated Swap (`ASC 815`) |
| CLO AAA/AA Senior Tranche vs CLO Equity Tranche | **AAA Passes** / **Equity Fails** (`B4.1.21`) | AAA = AC/FVOCI | Equity = **FVTPL** | HTM/AFS (`ASC 325-40` beneficial interest) |

## Prepayment Penalty Clauses: Negative Compensation Fixed in 2017 (`IFRS 9.B4.1.12A`)

Symmetric make-whole prepayment clauses—where prepaying a loan after market interest rates *spike* results in the borrower receiving a discount ("symmetric negative compensation")—were rescued via a 2017 IASB amendment confirming SPPI eligibility alongside [IFRS 9.4.4.1 reclassification and FVOCI rules](/wiki/htm-tainting-reclassification-afs-fvoci-amortized-cost-rules).

![Earnings and CET1 volatility comparison on a $10B Sustainability-Linked Loan portfolio classified at Amortized Cost vs FVTPL](/api/figure?type=bars&title=Impact%20of%20SPPI%20Pass%20vs%20Fail%20on%20a%20%2410.0B%207Y%20Green%20Loan%20Book%20%28%24M%29&subtitle=Evaluating%20%2B120%20bps%20Corporate%20Credit%20Spread%20Widening%20Shock%20Across%20IFRS%209%20Classifications&steps=Amortized%20Cost%20%28Pass%29%3A%3AMay%202024%20SPPI%20Pass%3A%20Stage%201%2F2%20ECL%20rises%20-%2438M%3B%20market%20liquidity%20spread%20ignored%20in%20P%26L%7CFVOCI%20%28HTC%26S%20Pass%29%3A%3ACredit%20ECL%20%28-%2438M%20P%26L%29%20%2B%20full%20-%24640M%20spread%20markdown%20hits%20OCI%20%2F%20CET1%20capital!%7CFVTPL%20%28SPPI%20Fail!%29%3A%3ANo%20ECL%20model%2C%20BUT%20full%20-%24678M%20market%20spread%20markdown%20slams%20Pre-Tax%20P%26L%20%26%20CET1%20Day%201!%7CUS%20GAAP%20Host%20%2B%20Deriv%3A%3AEven%20on%20non-basic%20feature%2C%20ASC%20815%20bifurcates%20ONLY%20the%20tiny%20embedded%20ratchet%20to%20P%26L!&metrics=AC%20P%26L%20Impact%3A%3A-%2438.0M%20ECL%3A%3ASmooth%20Banking%20Book%20NII%7CFVTPL%20P%26L%20Impact%3A%3A-%24678.0M%20Hit!%3A%3A18x%20Earnings%20Volatility!%7CESG%20SLL%20Market%3A%3A%241.5T%2B%20Global%3A%3ASaved%20From%20FVTPL%20Cliff%7CIFRS%207.20B%20Note%3A%3AMandatory%3A%3ADisclose%20Max%20Ratchet%20Range)

## IFRS 7.20B Quantitative Disclosures for Contingent ESG Cash Flows

When adopting the 2024 SPPI amendments, banks must disclose in [IFRS 7 financial statement notes](/wiki/ifrs-7-pillar-3-credit-risk-vintage-disclosures-audit-isa-540) the qualitative nature of ESG contingent events, maximum bps spread range, and gross carrying amount per class across the [IFRS 9, CECL & Fair Value Accounting topic hub](/topics/ifrs9-cecl-credit-provisioning).

```formula
Modified_TVM_Benchmark_Test : | PV(CF_Imperfect_Reset) - PV(CF_Benchmark_Exact_Tenor) | / Principal <= Materiality_Band
CLI_Tranche_SPPI_Gate : EL_or_VaR(Tranche_k) <= Weighted_Avg_EL_or_VaR(Underlying_SPPI_Asset_Pool)

Worked Modified Time-Value-of-Money Benchmark Test ($100.0M 5-Year Loan Resetting Monthly to the **5-Year Constant Maturity Swap [CMS]** Rate!):
 1. Imperfect Cash Flow: Resets every 1 month to the 5-Year CMS yield rather than 1-Month EURIBOR/SOFR!
 2. Benchmark Cash Flow: Identical loan resetting every 1 month to 1-Month EURIBOR/SOFR.
 3. Under Steepener/Inversion Scenarios (`SRP31` 2s5s shifts of +/-150 bps): Undiscounted/PV cash-flow divergence = $6.40M (6.4% of par)!
 4. Conclusion: Cash flows COULD be "significantly different" (IFRS 9.B4.1.9C) -> CMS-linked loan FAILS SPPI -> Must be measured at FVTPL!
```

## Frequently asked questions

### Why did IFRS 9 abolish embedded-derivative bifurcation on financial assets while keeping it on financial liabilities?

Under old IAS 39, splitting complex structured assets into host loans + bifurcated exotic derivatives proved subjective and error-prone; IFRS 9.4.3.1 simplified asset accounting by testing the whole asset under SPPI (sending failures to FVTPL), while preserving bifurcation on financial liabilities (IFRS 9.4.3.2) so banks cannot mark their entire bond issuance to FVTPL via tiny embedded features!

### Does a loan whose interest rate steps up +15 bps if the borrower’s revenue or EBITDA hits a target pass the 2024 SPPI rules?

NO — it STILL FAILS SPPI (IFRS 9.B4.1.10A)! Participating in upside borrower revenue, net income, or equity price is an equity-like return, not a basic lending arrangement! By contrast, a step-up if *Leverage (Debt / EBITDA) deteriorates* passes because Debt/EBITDA directly measures borrower credit default risk.

### Do Basel Tier 2 and AT1 CoCo bonds held by an institutional investor pass the IFRS 9 SPPI test?

AT1 CoCos categorically FAIL SPPI (100% FVTPL) due to discretionary non-cumulative coupon cancellation and going-concern write-down/equity conversion! Even Tier 2 / Bail-in MREL bonds: statutory bail-in powers imposed by law (BRRD) do *not* fail SPPI (B4.1.13), whereas *contractual* point-of-non-viability loss-absorption clauses going beyond statutory rankings require strict legal equivalence checks!

### What else did the May 2024 IASB IFRS 9 Amendments change besides ESG-linked SPPI?

The May 2024 package also clarified settlement-date derecognition of financial assets and liabilities settled via electronic payment systems—creating an accounting policy election to derecognize trade payables upon initiating an irrevocable electronic wire instruction before cash settles at the payee’s bank!


## Source URLs

- https://www.ifrs.org/news-and-events/news/2024/05/iasb-issues-amendments-classification-measurement-financial-instruments/
- https://www.ifrs.org/issued-standards/list-of-standards/ifrs-9-financial-instruments/
- https://www.esma.europa.eu/sites/default/files/2023-10/ESMA32-1283113657-1041_Public_Statement_on_Sustainability-linked_loans.pdf

## Citation

- APA: Arthur Pendleton, CPA, JD. (2026). IFRS 9 SPPI Cash-Flow Test & May 2024 IASB Amendments: ESG Sustainability-Linked Loans & Non-Recourse Debt. FinLexicon Wiki. https://finlexicon.org/wiki/sppi-solely-payments-principal-interest-esg-linked-loan-tests
- Canonical article: [IFRS 9 SPPI Cash-Flow Test & May 2024 IASB Amendments: ESG Sustainability-Linked Loans & Non-Recourse Debt](https://finlexicon.org/wiki/sppi-solely-payments-principal-interest-esg-linked-loan-tests)
- Site research index: [FinLexicon Wiki](https://finlexicon.org/llms-full.txt)
