Skip to content
FinLexicon Wiki
Directory

Isda Csa Derivatives Collateral

1992 ISDA Market Quotation & Loss vs 2002 Close-Out Amount: Section 6(e) Early Termination Valuation

Following the 1998 LTCM and 2008 Lehman crises where 4-dealer Market Quotation polls broke down, the 2002 ISDA Master Agreement introduced Close-Out Amount—blending executable third-party quotes, mid-market curves, and internal models.

By Arthur Pendleton, CPA, JDReview not recorded · Updated
1992 ISDA Market Quotation & Loss vs 2002 Close-Out Amount: Section 6(e) Early Termination Valuation — FinLexicon Wiki 2026 quantitative & supervisory data card
FinLexicon Wiki (2002 ISDA Master Agreement, VM/IM CSA, SIMM & Close-Out Netting): 1992 4-dealer Market Quotation & Loss vs 2002 Close-Out Amount objective reasonableness.Source: FinLexicon Wiki Institutional Research DeskLicense: CC-BY-4.0

Valuing 15,000 bespoke cross-currency swaps, swaptions, and exotic credit derivatives at 09:00 on the morning a global investment bank collapses is the ultimate stress test of financial contract law. Between the 1992 ISDA Master Agreement and the 2002 ISDA Master Agreement, Section 6(e) underwent a fundamental philosophical shift—retiring rigid four-dealer "Market Quotation" and subjective "Loss" in favor of the unified, commercially reasonable "Close-Out Amount" standard.

Why 1992 ISDA "Market Quotation" Failed During the 1998 LTCM and 2008 Lehman Panics#

Under the 1992 ISDA Master Agreement, parties typically elected Market Quotation (paired with Second Method two-way payment) as their primary close-out valuation yardstick within the ISDA single-agreement netting architecture. Mechanically, Market Quotation required the Non-Defaulting Party to:

  1. Solicit firm replacement quotes from four leading Reference Market-makers for the exact economic equivalent of each terminated transaction (or portfolio group).
  2. If all 4 quotes arrived, discard the highest and lowest and average the middle 2 quotes; if exactly 3 quotes arrived, select the middle quote.
  3. If fewer than 3 Reference Market-makers provided firm quotes—which happened on virtually every illiquid or large swap book during September 1998 (LTCM/Russia) and September 2008 (Lehman)—Market Quotation collapsed automatically into the fallback "Loss" definition!

Worse still, switching abruptly from rigid third-party bid/offer quotes (Market Quotation) to broad indemnity-style valuation (Loss) sparked years of billion-dollar courtroom battles over whether internal hedge unwinds, funding spreads, and own/counterparty credit spreads (CVA/DVA) could be priced into the claim!

Comparison workflow of 1992 ISDA 4-dealer Market Quotation fallback to Loss vs 2002 ISDA Close-Out Amount
Comparison workflow of 1992 ISDA 4-dealer Market Quotation fallback to Loss vs 2002 ISDA Close-Out AmountVerified Exhibit

Architecture of the 2002 ISDA "Close-Out Amount": Good Faith & Commercial Reasonableness#

Drafted directly from the lessons of 1998 Asian/Russian/LTCM defaults, the 2002 ISDA Master Agreement fused Market Quotation and Loss into a single, flexible, objectively policed metric: Close-Out Amount (Section 14).

Under Close-Out Amount, the Determining Party calculates the gains or losses it would incur in replacing—or providing the economic equivalent of—the material terms of the terminated transactions, acting in good faith and using commercially reasonable procedures in order to produce a commercially reasonable result!

Crucially, Section 14 explicitly authorizes a three-source data hierarchy without requiring 4 failed dealer phone calls first:

  • Firm or Indicative Third-Party Quotations (weighted by market liquidity and size).
  • Relevant External Market Data (observable broker screens, futures, OIS curves, vol surfaces).
  • Internal Pricing Models & Rate Curves—explicitly permitted whenever used by the Determining Party in the regular course of its business for valuing similar transactions with third parties!

Creditworthiness & Funding Spreads on Close-Out: Can Determining Parties Charge Bid-Ask & CVA?#

Look closely at two decisive valuation rules enforced by New York and English courts across dealers such as Bank of America, BNP Paribas, and Bank of Montreal:

  1. Exclusion of Defaulting Party’s Credit Spread (Credit-Risk-Free Replacement): Both Market Quotation and 2002 Close-Out Amount price replacement swaps assuming satisfaction of all conditions precedent (Section 2(a)(iii)) with a creditworthy replacement dealer (including existing 2016 VM CSA collateral terms!)—you cannot discount what you owe an insolvent counterparty by its 4,000 bps distressed CDS spread! (However, the Determining Party’s own creditworthiness* MAY be considered under 2002 Close-Out Amount when third-party dealers quote replacement levels to a weakened Determining Party!)*
  2. Executable Bid-Offer Crossing Cost (Concentration / Liquidity Add-On): Exiting a $15B DV01 swap book costs real dealer bid-ask crossing spread; courts uphold commercially reasonable portfolio-level bid-ask adjustments (netting offsetting risk buckets first rather than charging gross trade-by-trade bid-ask on 10,000 offsetting swaps!).
Quantitative Distribution · 1992 Market Quotation
1992 Market Quotation
01Primary Valuation Mechanism4 Reference Mar…02Standard of Judicial ReviewProcedural comp…03Consideration of Credit Sup…Silent/ambiguou…
Valuation Feature1992 Market Quotation1992 Loss (Fallback / Primary)2002 Close-Out Amount (Standard)
Primary Valuation Mechanism4 Reference Market-maker firm quotes (trim high/low)Broad good-faith total loss/gain determinationReplacement economic equivalent via quotes, data, or models
Standard of Judicial ReviewProcedural compliance with 4-dealer pollSubjective good faith (Wednesbury rationality in UK)Objective "commercially reasonable procedures & result"!
Use of Internal Pricing ModelsNot permitted unless <3 quotes trigger LossPermitted as fallback evidence of LossExplicitly permitted where used in BAU business
Consideration of Credit Support (CSA)Silent/ambiguous in 1992 pre-printed textConsidered economicallyExplicitly includes existing Credit Support Documents!
Determining Party’s Own CreditExcluded (assumes prime dealer)Debated in Lehman litigationMay be included where affecting replacement quotes

The 2009 ISDA Close-Out Amount Protocol: Upgrading Legacy 1992 Master Agreements#

Rather than repapering tens of thousands of legacy 1992 Schedules from scratch, institutional counterparties adhered to the 2009 ISDA Close-Out Amount Protocol, surgically replacing 1992 Market Quotation/Loss with the 2002 Close-Out Amount definition while preserving bespoke Schedule elections like Section 5 Cross-Default thresholds.

Close-out valuation dispersion on a $10B exotic swap book across mid-market, portfolio-netted Close-Out Amount, and disputed gross bid-ask
Close-out valuation dispersion on a $10B exotic swap book across mid-market, portfolio-netted Close-Out Amount, and disputed gross bid-askVerified Exhibit

Auditability of Close-Out Calculations Under Section 6(d)(i)#

Under Section 6(d)(i), the Determining Party must deliver a detailed written Close-Out Statement showing quotations, market data, and model inputs in reasonable detail—a key audit focus across the ISDA-2002-CSA 2026 Benchmark Standard and the 2002 ISDA Master Agreement, CSA & SIMM topic hub.

Formula or model from the articleNot independently verified
Early_Termination_Amount_6e = Sum_i CloseOut_Amount_i(Term_Currency) + Unpaid_Amounts_Due_to_Det - Unpaid_Amounts_Due_to_Def
  • CloseOutAmountPortfolio = PVMidCSA(NettingSet) + CrossingCost( NetBucketSensitivitiesDeltaVega )
  • [ Subject to Objective Standard: |CloseOutAmount - ExecutablePortfolioReplacement| <= MarketDispersion_Band ]
  • Worked Section 6(e) Settlement Statement (Defaulting Counterparty B; Determining Party A; USD Termination Currency):
  • 1. Mid-Market CSA-Discounted PV of 450 Terminated Swaps (in favor of Party A) = +$180.00M
  • 2. Portfolio-Netted Dealer Bid-Offer Replacement Charge (3.5 bps * $4.0M/bp Net DV01) = +$14.00M => Close-Out Amount = +$194.00M
  • 3. Unpaid Past-Due Coupons Owed to A (+$3.20M) minus Title-Transfer Cash VM Held by A (-$175.00M Unpaid Amount)
  • Net Section 6(e) Early Termination Payable by Defaulting Party B = $194.00M + $3.20M - $175.00M = +$22.20M!

Frequently asked questions

How did English courts distinguish the legal standard of 1992 "Loss" vs 2002 "Close-Out Amount"?

In *Fondazione Enasarco v Lehman Brothers Finance SA* [2015] EWHC 1307, the High Court explained that 1992 Loss requires only good faith and *Wednesbury* rationality (not perverse), whereas 2002 Close-Out Amount requires objective commercial reasonableness in both methodology and numerical outcome!

If the Non-Defaulting Party actually executes a replacement swap in the market, is the Determining Party bound to that exact trade price?

Under 2002 Close-Out Amount, an arm’s-length replacement hedge or auction executed promptly in the market is powerful—often decisive—evidence of replacement value, provided the auction/execution itself followed commercially reasonable procedures (not a sweetheart affiliate print!).

How does Variation Margin already held enter the Section 6(e) Early Termination formula?

Under an English Law Title Transfer CSA, posted VM forms a Conditional Return "Transaction" whose value enters Unpaid Amounts directly inside Section 6(e); under a New York Law Security Interest CSA, Section 6(e) computes the gross swap Close-Out Amount first, and Paragraph 8 of the NY CSA sets off pledged collateral immediately against it!

Can a Determining Party include Hedge Accounting break costs or regulatory capital (KVA) in Close-Out Amount?

Hedging losses/gains directly incurred in unwinding hedges of the terminated transactions may be considered as evidence of replacement cost, whereas internal regulatory capital charges (KVA) that a third-party market maker would not charge in an executable replacement swap price are generally disallowed.

Publication record

Published
14 November 2026
Updated
15 November 2026
Author
Arthur Pendleton, CPA, JD
Review
Review not recorded
Automated fact check
Passed in the stored pipeline record
Source URLs
3 recorded

AI assistance recorded: anthropic/claude-opus-4.6. This field does not establish human review or source verification.

Academic & Institutional Attribution

Cite This Research & Embed Live Data Card

Open Attribution License (CC BY 4.0)

Standard academic & institutional research paper citation format.

Arthur Pendleton, CPA, JD. (2026, November 15). 1992 ISDA Market Quotation & Loss vs 2002 Close-Out Amount: Section 6(e) Early Termination Valuation. FinLexicon Wiki. https://finlexicon.org/wiki/isda-1992-market-quotation-loss-vs-2002-close-out-amount
Explore Isda Csa Derivatives Collateral Hub (20) →

FinLexicon Wiki Data, Benchmarks & Contributor Records

1992 ISDA Market Quotation vs 2002 Close-Out Amount Guide | FinLexicon Wiki